ANDERSON, Ind. —
This is the fourth in a series of articles concerning various facts and opinions about black history, how that history affects black leadership today, and what I think are the implications for black leadership in the future. It’s a much weightier subject than I thought.
For example, I wrote last week about Abraham Lincoln and my feelings that he might have been morally opposed to slavery, but that he signed the Emancipation Proclamation for practical, political and military reasons. Now, here is the problem.
All my life, mainly as a result of schooling from kindergarten through college, I put Abraham Lincoln on a pedestal. You know, the Great Emancipator. Honest Abe. Robin Hood. Superman. Batman, and those heroes.
After all, in the 1960s, didn’t Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. stand at the foot of the Lincoln Memorial when he delivered his famous “I Have a Dream” speech to the world? The only thing I have ever regretted about the historic event is that I was not there, weeping and cheering like all the rest.
Then, in the process of writing these articles, I did something we are not supposed to do. It’s something called research. I looked a little deeper into “Honest Abe.” Well, I came across a passage from the great contemporary historian Lerone Bennett Jr.
A thoughtful scholar, he is best known for his classic book on black history, Before the Mayflower. But the passage I read came from another of his many history books — “Forced Into Glory: Abraham Lincoln’s White Dream.”
Bennett’s facts are indisputable, and well known to every serious historian. The only controversy about it is that it paints quite a different picture of Lincoln than what we are taught in school.
First, Bennett asserts that Lincoln, like many in his era, thought blacks were inherently inferior to whites.
Second, although he did, in fact, sign the Emancipation Proclamation, he did so reluctantly.
Third, he firmly believed that the best thing for America to do with her 4,000,000 black slaves was send them all back to Africa. He believed that “deporting blacks and creating an all-white country was a moral imperative.”
Historical records show that Lincoln said: “Let us be brought to believe it is morally right and, at the same time, favorable to, or, at least, not against, our interest, to transfer the African to his native clime, and we shall find a way to do it, however great the task may be.”€
Bennett also notes: “One reads everywhere or almost everywhere that Lincoln had to talk like a racist because of the racist atmosphere of the time. This apology overlooks the relatively large number of white politicians who acted and voted for freedom despite racism.”
The Emancipation Proclamation did not free a single slave. It took the 13th and 14th constitutional amendments to accomplish that, along with incredible pressure from white politicians and growing numbers of black and white citizens to at last bring human slavery to an end.
This point illuminates a larger issue. American history is shrouded in myth. The credit for some of our greatest human accomplishments is often given to the wrong person or group. And, conversely, the blame for some of our country’s greatest failures is laid at the feet of the innocent.
Anyway, by the end of the Civil War, in 1865, over 200,000 black men had served in the Union army, fighting for freedom for all African-Americans. Over 600,000 soldiers on both sides lay dead. And huge portions of the South lay in ruins.
For African Americans, what followed was a brief period of freedom and prosperity known as the Reconstruction Era. The era lasted approximately 12 years, and saw thousands of Southern blacks become successful elected officials, businessmen, preachers, farmers, skilled tradesmen, educators, housewives, and so forth.
As to education, because of the great passion of newly freed African-Americans to learn to read, write, and compute, America’s system of public education was born. After all, illiteracy was not a problem peculiar to blacks alone. The shoe fit millions of White southerners as well.
Looked at another way, the end of slavery marked the beginning of profound changes in the contours of American society. These changes would not come easily and, in many ways, are still emerging. More bluntly stated, following the Reconstruction Era, there would be blood.
Have a nice day.
Primus Mootry is an Anderson resident. His column is published each Wednesday.
Columns
Primus Mootry: Black leadership in 21st century — lessons from the past
- Columns
-
-
Verna Davis: Church and state — separation or silence?
It’s time we realize, as Charles J. Chaput says, that “exiling religion from civic debates separates government from morality...That road leads to politics without character.” It’s time we realize that it’s time to speak up. The future of our country depends on our doing just that.
-
Heather Bremer: Can Smith cash in on another Big Willie Weekend?
After yet another four-year break, Will Smith once again ventures into waters of the summertime box office with today’s debut of “Men in Black III.” Luckily for Big Willie, it’s the first weekend in ages that won’t be ruled by “The Avengers” … probably.
-
Susan Miller: Looking for a summer vacation vocation
Summer vacation is often a synonym for summer vocation, particularly for teenagers.
-
Jim Bailey: Amazing races keep things lively for family in May
Used to be when you spoke of a race in May, the Indianapolis 500 came to mind. For our family this year that will be an afterthought.
-
Primus Mootry: The Great Divide continues in the U.S.
Last Saturday, at a South Carolina GOP fundraiser attended by a thousand people, Sen. Marco Rubio, R-Fla., labeled President Barack Obama as the most “divisive figure in modern American history.” Sen. Rubio is certainly entitled to that opinion, but that’s all it is — an opinion.
-
Emmett Dulaney: Today’s actions hurt tomorrow
I have no recollection of why, but for some reason when we were kids my brother could not stand Catfish Hunter.
-
Bill Stanczykiewicz: Managing disagreements can be teens' gifts for Mom and Dad
New research suggests that teenagers who are allowed to disagree with their parents are more likely to resist negative peer pressure and avoid dangerous behaviors such as drug and alcohol use.
-
Scott Underwood: Good news plays role in journalism
The refrain from readers is almost constant in the careers of serious community journalists: You guys print too much bad news and ignore the good news.
-
Charo Boyd: Social Security serves wounded warriors, families
It’s an American tradition to pay tribute to the men and women of the Armed Forces each Memorial Day — especially honoring those who have made the ultimate sacrifice while serving our country.
-
Maureen Hayden: Readers say it best in response to column about primary
In a recent column, I posed a question about why only 19 percent of Indiana’s 4 million voters cast a ballot in the May primary. I promised not to chastise anyone who would ’fess up to not voting.
I’ll keep part of the promise: I won’t do the scolding, but will let someone else heap on a bit of shame. - More Columns Headlines
-




