Within the past two years, Indiana public schools have been hit with a triple whammy.
* Property tax caps were implemented and the state funding formula changed to give schools fewer resources.
* The economy went sour.
* Rules were changed to allow students to transfer to other districts, with the per-pupil average of $6,000 from the state following them to their new district.
Taken singly, any of these developments would have been bad news for many public schools. Combined, they’ve ushered in a time of unparalleled budget crises for most school districts.
The last whammy — the transfer rule — promotes school choice for parents and students, which is a good thing. It also fosters a spirit of competition among schools, pumping up the ambition to excel, to make the district desirable for transfers. That’s also a good thing.
However, school districts were given a great degree of latitude in setting rules for students they would accept. And that’s a bad thing.
Many districts — South Madison Schools being one example — have set standards that ensure they’re accepting only transfer students who have good academic credentials and good behavioral records. While it’s certainly understandable that individual districts don’t want troublemakers coming in, it limits the options of students who are looking for a new environment and a fresh start, or those who want scholastic and extracurricular options not offered by their home district.
The transfer rule would be more fair to these students if schools were not allowed to “cherry pick” transfers but instead were required either to take the transfers on a first-come, first-served basis or through a lottery system like the one used by Burris Laboratory School in Muncie.
Such an unbiased selection system would give all students, regardless of their past record of achievement, a more equitable chance at going to the district of their choice.
Indiana’s educational system, as dictated by the state constitution, is designed to be egalitarian, to provide a good education for every child. It’s not intended to be elitist or selective, favoring excellent students over those who struggle.
The way the transfer law is set up now, it promotes elitism.
Editorials
Editorial: Public school transfer rule defies state constitution
- Editorials
-
-
Editorial: Sentencing should be determined by judge most familiar with case
We should show concern about the handling of a criminal’s recent case under the Madison County unified court system, a concept where judges share resources to help reduce costs, avoid backlogs and move cases forward.
-
Editorial: 911 consolidation good for county
When it comes to emergencies, a fast and proper response is sometimes the difference between life and death. Therefore it is important for 911 services to be coordinated for the best response time. It’s even better if those services are consolidated with one location fielding calls from multiple areas.
-
Editorial: On Valentine’s Day, indulge in selfishness of volunteering
In the final analysis, we’re all selfish beings. Everything we do, at its core, is motivated by what is good for us.
-
You Said It: About roundabouts, Mayor Smith’s firings, recycling, State of City address
The bottom line in Mayor Kevin Smith’s State of the City address Tuesday during the Anderson Rotary Club’s luncheon at Anderson Country Club was simple: To attract investment, you have to make investments. (Article published Feb. 4.)
-
Editorial: Firings show inability to turn foes into friends
Politics is a double-edged sword.
-
Editorial: Help celebrate city's strong black history
Many times we overlook the small achievements of residents long gone who made a better Anderson for those of us alive today. There is no better time to recognize and cherish those stories than during Black History Month.
-
Editorial: Madison County needs vision for future tourism
Slot machines, gospel music, a beautiful state park and candy are all thriving as destination sites. Now is the time to explore a way to connect these valuable attractions and encourage new ideas.
-
Editorial: AHS grad rates moving up, must be pushed ever higher
A diploma is a must, but it has to mean something. Anderson High School must do this the right way, not cutting corners and passing students through classes, but making them accountable for learning the subject matter.
-
Editorial: With changes to program, why not begin recycling?
The public has to understand the importance of recycling aluminum and steel cans, cardboard, glass, newspapers and certain plastics. Besides minimizing a community’s waste, recycling saves energy, natural resources and the environment.
-
Editorial: Reality returns after Super Bowl mania
While we loved what the Super Bowl did for our reputation, it’s time to get back to the real world. Let’s recap the lost week.
- More Editorials Headlines
-
