A free press is essential to a functioning democracy. How a free press is used, however, is subject to endless debate. For example, the press will say that it needs to protect sources so they won’t suffer reprisals from the information they reveal. Others say such blanket protection can shield lawbreakers.
Indiana has a shield law that describes a journalist and goes on to say that person shall not be compelled to disclose in legal proceedings or elsewhere the source of information obtained.
With this kind of protection, sources are free to become whistleblowers and the press can get out information on public officials that wouldn’t see the light of day without such a law.
Congress is reluctant to pass such a law on the federal level. Indiana Rep. Mike Pence put forth a federal shield law in the House although the Bush administration opposed it. The executive branch cited national security reasons for taking such a stance.
The absence of this law allowed federal prosecutor Patrick Fitzgerald to vigorously pursue journalists such as the New York Times’ Judith Miller who spent 85 days in jail for not cooperating in front of a grand jury about what she knew in the Valerie Plame leak case.
On Monday, Fitzgerald brought Miller, no longer a Times reporter, back and tried to get more information about the Plame case including the newspaper’s phone records.
Without a shield law, the federal government is free to pursue journalists, and no government has been more bold in this approach than the current administration. The U.S. citizens become the losers because information is withheld and made secret. Secrecy is anathema to a government for the people and by the people.
Before Pence introduced his bill, Indiana Sen. Richard Lugar had co-authored a similar bill. We applaud them for making a move that is long overdue.
National security is the blanket statement used by administration after administration to keep information secret that needs to be put in front of the public. This holds public officials accountable.
In April, the 2006 Freedom of Information Summit will be held in Indianapolis and will concentrate on teaching everyone — journalists as well as ordinary residents — community access laws. Pence will be a guest speaker. This is an important topic for all Americans. The freedom to collect and receive unvarnished information will always be challenged by those not wanting to be exposed. For a democracy, however, such disclosure is necessary for people to know what their leaders are doing.
Editorials
Needed: federal shield law
- Editorials
-
-
Editorial: Madison County needs vision for future tourism
Slot machines, gospel music, a beautiful state park and candy are all thriving as destination sites. Now is the time to explore a way to connect these valuable attractions and encourage new ideas.
-
Editorial: AHS grad rates moving up, must be pushed ever higher
A diploma is a must, but it has to mean something. Anderson High School must do this the right way, not cutting corners and passing students through classes, but making them accountable for learning the subject matter.
-
Editorial: With changes to program, why not begin recycling?
The public has to understand the importance of recycling aluminum and steel cans, cardboard, glass, newspapers and certain plastics. Besides minimizing a community’s waste, recycling saves energy, natural resources and the environment.
-
Editorial: Reality returns after Super Bowl mania
While we loved what the Super Bowl did for our reputation, it’s time to get back to the real world. Let’s recap the lost week.
-
You Said It: About contract, 'Teen Mom,' State of the City
Each Monday, The Herald Bulletin publishes “You Said It,” a compilation of reader comments from www.theheraldbulletin.com, coupled with responses by the newspaper’s editorial board.
-
Editorial: Smith speech shows mayor aiming high
The bottom line in Mayor Kevin Smith’s State of the City address Tuesday during the Anderson Rotary Club’s luncheon at Anderson Country Club was simple: To attract investment, you have to make investments.
-
Editorial: Bill offered by state Senate honors Fourth Amendment
No law is ever going to rid domestic situations of their subjectivity, but people have a right to be secure in their homes, and the police need to keep this in mind when they come knocking.
-
Editorial: Burton's retirement was overdue
Dan Burton has been a fixture in Indiana politics for nearly a half century. A staunch Republican, Burton made waves in the Statehouse and in Congress, but now it’s over. Burton recently announced his retirement and will not seek re-election in Indiana’s District 5.
-
Editorial: Tempered excitement for call-center jobs is prudent
Immediately after city officials announced the location of a new call center in Anderson on Jan. 25, the “Yeah, buts ...” started.
-
Editorial: Trigger law would give parents too much power
If the state is going to push for charter schools, it has to be a measured action with plenty of debate. There is a reason why the term trigger-happy has negative connotations. It means a knee-jerk reaction with little thought.
- More Editorials Headlines
-
Editorial: Madison County needs vision for future tourism
