The Herald Bulletin

Morning Update

Local Education

July 26, 2010

South Madison can’t charge ‘pay to play’

Board member says fee violates state constitution

PENDLETON, Ind. — The school board has chosen to forgo imposing “pay to play” fees on students this coming school year, but the board didn’t have much choice in the matter, according to South Madison board member Chris Boots.

The South Madison Community School Corp. had been considering charging students fees to participate in extracurricular activities.

Superintendent Tom Warmke said that a fee schedule was established for the board’s consideration.

The schedule would have meant that each high school student would pay $50 per sport with students on the free and reduced lunch program paying $25.

Middle school students would pay $30 per sport, with free and reduced lunch students paying $15 per sport.

Warmke said the fees would be capped and participation in a third sport would not be charged.

On Monday, Boots said the school board backed away from the plan, not because it dislikes the plan, but because it learned the fee might be unconstitutional.

That’s because a cost-saving measure taken by the school district last year has plunged the school district into a unique conundrum.

Last year, after hearing that it was an option from Superintendent of Public Education Tony Bennett, the school district began offering school physical education credit to those participating in athletics, cheerleading and marching band.

This allowed the school to eliminate one physical education teaching position, Warmke said.

While “pay to play” would save the school $35,000, he said, the elimination saved at least $63,000.

In Indiana, public schools cannot charge tuition to students because it flies in the face of the Indiana Constitution, Boots said.

Since extracurricular activities now earn academic credit, charging students to participate would equate to charging tuition, he said.

Boots said the board learned this after the Indiana State School Board Association issued a warning to schools thinking of imposing fees.

“I think that’s why the board is saying i don’t know if we can do that or not,” Boots said.

Warmke said the board didn’t want to burden families. “I think part of it was because of the money it would generate not being a significant amount and the problems it could possibly create for some families that are financially stressed.”

Boots said the fee structure being proposed by cash-strapped schools across the state could be called into question as well.

“It’s opened a big can of worms. Our hands are really tied at this point,” he said.

Contact Brandi Watters, 640-4847, brandi.watters@heraldbulletin.com        

Text Only
Local Education
  • 0530 news cleanup boynton.jpg End-of-school year trip has community service in mind

    Seventh-grader Parker Jones thought his end-of-the-school year field trip might be going to the zoo. But on Tuesday, he was among more than 150 seventh-graders picking up trash at the Pendleton Sports Complex for a field trip aimed at community service.

    May 29, 2012 1 Photo

  • 0530 comm students serve.jpg New perspective: AHS students serve and learn

    Seniors in the Anderson High School Fellowship of Christian Athletes have been heading over to the Christian Center on Main Street once a month to serve lunch.

    May 29, 2012 1 Photo

  • Academic Accolades: May 27

    A compilation of academic news as published in the Sunday edition of The Herald Bulletin.

    May 26, 2012

  • 0526 news AHS student appreciation day03a.jpg Well-behaved students rewarded with carnival

    A “Can you survive the yuck?” game was one of many offered at the Student Appreciation Program held inside and on the outdoor grounds of AHS on Friday.

    May 25, 2012 1 Photo

  • 0525 news last day of class 05.jpg Indiana Christian Academy students look ahead to summer

    Tantalizing Florida vacations filled with sun, sand, sea and Disney shimmered like diamonds strewn across a distant shore for several kids awaiting pickup on the last day of classes at Indiana Christian Academy Thursday.

    May 24, 2012 1 Photo

  • AHS rewarding well-behaved students

    Anderson High School is holding its Student Appreciation Program (SAP) Friday for students who meet or surpass several requirements.

    May 24, 2012

  • AHS will hold student appreciation day

    Anderson High School is holding its Student Appreciation Program Friday for students who meet or surpass several requirements.

    May 24, 2012

  • 0524 comm AHS choir rehearsing 32a.jpg Anderson High School choir to sing with Foreigner

    When Julie Wood received an email from Hoosier Park Racing & Casino about an “exciting opportunity,” the Anderson High School director of choral activities thought it was a joke.

    May 23, 2012 3 Photos

  • 0523 spts Red Haven Award winner 11a.jpg Haffner becomes 44th winner of Red Haven Award

    Pendleton Heights now has both the old and the new Red Haven Award trophy for its case at school.
    When PH’s Ellie McCardwell won the award in 2010, the long-standing trophy was retired, and because the Arabians had the last winner, the school was able to permanently house that hardware.
    On Tuesday, when the Anderson Noon Exchange Club presented the 2012 winner, it went to Pendleton Heights’ Abbie Haffner. So for the next 12 months, PH will be home to both the new traveling trophy, first presented a year ago to Lapel’s Leigh Steele, and the old one.

    May 23, 2012 1 Photo

  • 1010_stand_learning_center001.JPG Anderson Learning Academy withdraws charter application

    When Anderson Learning Academy’s board first started seeking charter status, it was to help make changes in education as graduation rates and ISTEP scores were low in the public school system.

    May 22, 2012 1 Photo