ANDERSON — A court ruling in which an Anderson father’s religion was a determining factor to strip him of joint custody of his three children is cause for concern, an Indiana University law professor said.
Craig Scarberry of Anderson lost joint custody of his three children this month after Madison County Superior Court 3 Commissioner George C. Pancol issued an order that included court evidence that Scarberry, formerly a Christian, had become agnostic. The order was affirmed by Superior Court 3 Judge Thomas Newman.
Jennifer Drobac, an Indiana University professor specializing in family law, said a parent’s religion has no place in custody decisions.
“Father has a reason to be concerned,” Drobac wrote in an e-mail, suggesting the ruling might violate Scarberry’s First Amendment constitutional right to freedom of religion.
“I have read the order and am really concerned about why (Pancol) twice mentioned (Scarberry’s) religious beliefs,” Drobac wrote. “Such discretion would be clearly unconstitutional unless the parent’s religious practices were actually harming or posed a substantial threat of harm to the children.”
The ruling reduced Scarberry’s custody of his elementary-school-age children to alternating weekends plus four hours a week. Scarberry has until Dec. 1 to appeal the ruling.
Scarberry has obtained a permit for a fathers’ rights rally at the Madison County Courthouse on Dec. 16.
Pancol, who previously declined to discuss the case, said again Tuesday that it would be unethical for him to comment.
“This country was established, in part, because of a desire for religious freedom. The First Amendment protects all religious perspectives, not just Christian ones,” Drobac wrote.
Contact Dave Stafford: 648-4250, dave.stafford@heraldbulletin.com
Local News
Custody ruling raises legal concerns
IU law expert: Order against agnostic father a reason for concern
- Local News
-
-
Elevated levels of PCBs found
Three city Water Pollution Control employees were disciplined recently after failing to notify supervisors that dried sludge used as fertilizer by some area farmers contained elevated levels of banned PCBs.
-
State aims up with college graduate plan
Indiana higher-education policymakers are getting ready to adopt an aggressive college-completion plan that will push the state’s universities to reel in their rising costs and dramatically improve their graduation rates.
-
College credit transfer bill awaits governor’s signature
The Indiana General Assembly is moving ahead on efforts to contain college costs, which have risen more than 100 percent over the last decade.
-
Four groups interested in leasing Grandview restaurant space
Four groups have submitted proposals to lease the vacant restaurant space at Grandview Golf Course.
-
Mardi Gras celebration precedes Lent
New Orleans jazz filled the hallway inside St. Mary’s School Tuesday night, as people snacked on Dorritos, cookies and cake — all part of the church’s Mardi Gras celebration.
-
Mix of clouds and sun
Expect a mix of clouds and sun today, with a few sprinkles possible. High temperaturees will be near 50 degrees. Highs are in the 50s on Thursday, too, but there is a better chance for a few showers.
-
Poll question for Wednesday, Feb. 22
Vote daily in The Herald Bulletin poll. Today's poll question can be found at the bottom of the homepage on the right side.
-
Arrest log: Feb. 22
Arrests made by Madison County law enforcement on Monday and Tuesday, based on Madison County Jail records.
-
Sugarland devastated by fair collapse comments
Country duo Sugarland says it is devastated that people "want to point fingers and try to sensationalize" an Aug. 13 stage collapse that killed seven people and injured 58 before the band's show at the Indiana State Fair.
-
Starting off with scattered showers
Today will start off with scattered showers. Most of the afternoon will be dry, with a mix of clouds and sun and a stray shower.
- More Local News Headlines
-
