ANDERSON — A city councilman has filed a lawsuit against the city, claiming nearly $75,000 in fees associated with his brokering an insurance contract with the city is being withheld for political reasons.
Art M. Pepelea Jr., R-District 5, filed the lawsuit Wednesday in Madison Superior Court 1, nearly four months after he sent a notice of tort claim to city officials saying a lawsuit was a possibility if the city didn’t settle the claim. A notice of tort claim is a declaration to a government agency that a civil lawsuit is being filed against it.
Anthem Insurance is also named as a defendant in the lawsuit, which claims Pepelea is owed $74,806.80 for a lost commission tied to a city employee health insurance contract.
“No one in this administration has had the courage or backbone to call me and tell me why this was done,” Pepelea said Thursday. “This is politics at its truest form.”
According to the lawsuit:
Pepelea, also an insurance agent, acted as a broker for Anthem when the city entered into a contract with the firm in 2007 to direct the city’s self-funded health benefits plan for 2008.
Each year, the city opens up the process for insurers to submit bids to administer the plan. Anthem had been doing the job since 2005, but Pepelea didn’t seek a broker’s commission on any contract until the one signed in 2007 covering 2008.
When Pepelea campaigned for a city council seat in 2003, he pledged to lower insurance costs and made the promise not to accept a brokerage fee. When he campaigned for re-election in 2007, he didn’t make the same campaign promise, he said, citing other insurance brokers doing business with the city that were earning fees.
“They’re paying everyone else; why shouldn’t I get paid?” Pepelea said. “I’m a professional. Why shouldn’t I get paid? It’s what I do for a living.”
In November 2007, the city council again approved a contract with Anthem for 2008, and then-City Controller Morris Long and then-Deputy Mayor Rob Sparks signed off on the deal. In that contract, a nearly $75,000 brokerage commission was included, and the city council and city administrators were aware of the charge. Pepelea didn’t vote on the contract.
The same day the contract was to start on Jan. 1, newly sworn-in Anderson Mayor Kris Ockomon sent a letter to Anthem officials to stop Pepelea’s commission and to ask for a new broker.
“The City of Anderson unilaterally requested a modification of an in-place contract to single out and harm Pepelea,” Pepelea’s attorney, Mark Dudley, writes in the complaint. “Pepelea is a Republican. Mayor Ockomon is a Democrat.”
Ockomon declined comment Thursday, referring questions to City Attorney Tim Lanane. Lanane said withholding the brokerage fees wasn’t politically motivated.
“That’s not true,” he said. “All of a sudden, in the last days of the previous administration, he seeks (brokerage) fees.”
Lanane said city officials were still reviewing the suit, but said the city expected Anthem to pay Pepelea’s fees, and thought that should have been reflected in the contract with the insurance company.
“It’s been confusing,” Lanane said. “The bottom line is, it was going to come from the city’s coffers.”
Along with the $75,000, Pepelea is also seeking attorney fees and other costs.
-----------
What’s next? A trial date has not yet been set in Anderson City Councilman Art Pepelea’s lawsuit against the city. Pepelea is seeking nearly $75,000 in disputed insurance brokerage fees.
Local News
11:53 p.m.: Councilman Pepelea suing city
- Local News
-
-
Rivals back home, friends here
Football fans began arriving here for Super Bowl XLVI on Friday, bringing together complete strangers, families and old fraternity buddies.
-
Pats tats are sign of pride for Indy police officer
There’s no love lost in this Super Bowl host city for the New England Patriots, but it’s no crime to be a Pats fan. Just ask Indianapolis police Officer Mike Andresen.
-
Wireless infrastructure to be tested under heavy demand
The throngs of fans who’ll descend on Lucas Oil Stadium for Sunday’s Super Bowl game may experience the most “connected” game in the event’s history, thanks to an estimated $100 million investment in technology infrastructure in and around the stadium.
-
Brothers arrested, charged with trafficking
Two men were being held at the Madison County Jail Friday after being arrested and charged with felonies at the Pendleton Correctional Facility Thursday night.
-
Police respond to shooting on 10th Street
Police responded late Friday evening to a reported shooting at a residence on West 10th Street.
-
Local Briefs: Feb. 4
A compilation of news items of local and statewide interest as published in the Saturday edition of the Herald Bulletin.
-
Arrest log: Feb. 4
Arrests made by Madison County law enforcement on Thursday and Friday, based on Madison County Jail records.
-
Super Car on display at Mounds Mall
Residents wanting to be a part of the super celebration have another opportunity to do so by visiting Mounds Mall to get an up-close look at one of 33 NFL franchise-themed Indy cars.
-
Once in a lifetime
When it was announced that Indianapolis would host Super Bowl XLVI in 2012, Michelle Brandle and her close friends raced to get online and sign up for a spot to volunteer.
-
Leadership Academy graduates class of 2012
Thursday night marked at least two milestones for the Leadership Academy of Madison County.
It marked the 30th graduating class from the academy, and the attendance at the annual graduation dinner at Anderson Country Club set a new record of 167. - More Local News Headlines
-
