The Herald Bulletin

Afternoon Update

Sports

Related Photos

Discussion

March 9, 2010

Quintin Harlan: Toney set to test MMA

James “Lights Out” Toney’s status in the world of boxing should be secure.

His career record stands 72-6-3 with two no contests and 44 wins coming by way of knockout. He’s a former world champion in four weight classes, and he’s the current NABO and IBF heavyweight champion.

And he’s the newest member of the Ultimate Fighting Championships.

Since the sport of mixed martial arts started gaining in popularity and mainstream exposure, there’s been a debate about which combat-sport was better: boxing or MMA.

And the natural follow-up question — would a boxer beat an MMA fighter and vice versa in each respective sport?

The answer of “it depends on the rules” didn’t seem to appease many. If an MMA fighter competes in a boxing match, the odds should favor the boxer, and if a boxer competes in MMA then, in theory, the MMA fighter should have the advantage.

Another former heavyweight champion, “Merciless” Ray Mercer, also has ventured into the MMA world. He had an exhibition fight against Kevin Ferguson, aka Kimbo Slice, and was submitted in the first round in June 2007. Mercer then fought former UFC heavyweight champ Tim Sylvia and duked Sylvia within the first 10 seconds of the first round.

Mercer’s bouts were on smaller shows. Toney is jumping right into the deep end of the sport with the UFC.

Toney’s first fight date and opponent have yet to be named, but odds have Toney’s debut being sometime this summer.

Now, Mercer showed the obvious, that a boxer’s punching power can translate very well from the ring to the cage. He also displayed this against Sylvia, who hasn’t scored a takedown since 2004.

Toney possesses KO power. But will he develop the other skills necessary to make it in mixed martial arts?

Indianapolis’ Chris “Lights Out” Lytle has been famous for stand-up wars in his recent outings. But in his last fight at UFC 110 in Sydney, Australia, on Feb. 21, Lytle scored a submission victory on Brian Foster via kneebar.

Lytle has a black belt in Brazilian jiu-jitsu. He’s also a former pro-boxer, but he started out as a wrestler in high school.

Arguably the UFC’s most famous fighter is former light-heavyweight champion “The Iceman” Chuck Liddell. Liddell’s preferred style of fighting is called sprawl and brawl. During his title reign, Liddell won five straight fights by either KO or technical knockout in a 20-month stretch.

While Liddell’s bread and butter is kickboxing, he also has a background in wrestling and jiu-jitsu.

The point here is that you cannot be one-dimensional and hope to have a continuous streak of success.

Toney is 41 years old and has been boxing his entire professional fighting life. Can he make the transition? Time will tell.



Contact Quintin Harlan: 640-4835, quintin.harlan@heraldbulletin.com.

Text Only
Sports
  • 0530 sports phhs vs roncalli 048.jpg Pendleton Heights falls to Roncalli in regional

    In the Class 4A Regional Tuesday, Roncalli scored the game-winning run in a 3-0 victory over Pendleton Heights on a wild pitch during an intentional walk to North Carolina-bound star Kendra Lynch in the sixth inning at Legends Field in Pendleton.

    May 29, 2012 2 Photos

  • 0530 spts slyder.jpg AU men's basketball coach resigns

    Anderson University head men’s basketball coach Tom Slyder recently resigned to accept a position as the men’s basketball coach at North Park University in Chicago, Ill.
    North Park is an NCAA Division III school that competes in the College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin (CCIW).

    May 29, 2012 1 Photo

  • DSC_1432.JPG Triumphant Tribe

    Seventeen years of frustration and disappointment for the Anderson Indians baseball team ended in a jubilant dog pile atop junior pitcher Curtis Wilson on Monday night at Pendleton Heights’ Field of Dreams.

    May 28, 2012 1 Photo

  • Argylls squeeze into crown

    Madison-Grant coach Ben Rodriguez liked his squeeze play so much that he called it again in the pivotal inning of the Class 2A, Sectional 39 championship game at Eastern High School on Monday night in Greentown.

    May 28, 2012

  • 0529 spts Lapel vs Wapahani_baseball 59a.jpg Bulldogs’ comeback falls just short

    Not even a heroic seventh-inning rally could save the Lapel baseball team in the Class 2A sectional title game at Frankton on Monday afternoon. The Bulldogs scored four runs in the seventh inning but still came up a run short as the Wapahani Raiders won the championship 9-8.

    May 28, 2012 1 Photo

  • 0413 sports Muller semifinal 038.jpg Tribe rallies past Pendleton Heights into final

    This is the stuff of legend.
    The kind of game that defines a rivalry.
    The kind of victory that breathes new life into a program.
    And the kind of defeat that won’t ever be forgotten.

    May 28, 2012 1 Photo

  • George Bremer-2.JPG George Bremer: In with Orton, out of Luck?

    There really is no offseason anymore in the National Football League.
    The Indianapolis Colts haven’t played a game since Jan. 1, but look at all the headlines they’ve generated since that date.

    May 28, 2012 1 Photo

  • de la Bastide-color.jpg Ken de la Bastide: Indy 500 lives up to hype - again

    For the second consecutive year the Indianapolis 500 demonstrated why it remains as “The Greatest Spectacle in Racing”.
    Last year there was the dramatic finish when rookie J.R. Hildebrand crashed in the fourth corner on the final lap allowing the late Dan Wheldon to record his second victory.

    May 29, 2012 1 Photo

  • 0528 NASCAR Charlotte Auto_Harl.jpg Kahne keeps Hendrick success rolling at Charlotte

    Kasey Kahne powered to victory in the Coca-Cola 600 on Sunday night, taking NASCAR's longest race for the third time for his first win with Hendrick Motorsports.

    May 27, 2012 1 Photo

  • 0528 Manu.jpg Spurs strike first in West finals, win 19th in row

    Manu Ginobili scored 26 points and the San Antonio Spurs won their 19th in a row to tie the NBA record for longest winning streak kept alive in the playoffs, beating the Oklahoma City Thunder 101-98 to open the Western Conference finals on Sunday night.

    May 27, 2012 1 Photo