The Herald Bulletin

Evening Update

Sports

February 5, 2012

Now, not then

Coaches, QBs remain, but much has changed for Pats, Giants since Super Bowl XLII

INDIANAPOLIS — The New England Patriots will attempt to make history today in Super Bowl XLVI at Lucas Oil Stadium.

But history is on the New York Giants’ side.

In the NFL’s big game, revenge is a dish rarely served at all.

Just two franchises in the event’s 45-year history ever have avenged a previous loss in the title game.

The Washington Redskins were the first to do it, knocking off the Miami Dolphins in Super Bowl XVII 10 years after becoming the final victim of the Dolphins’ perfect season.

The Dallas Cowboys are the most recent avengers, scoring a Super Bowl XXX victory against the Pittsburgh Steelers after losses in Super Bowl X and Super Bowl XIII.

The Giants famously won Super Bowl XLII four years ago in Glendale, Ariz., to end the Patriots’ bid at their own unbeaten campaign.

That shared history was a common topic during the past week in Indianapolis, but both teams quickly moved to distance themselves from that game.

“This group of young men is trying to create history for themselves,” New York head coach Tom Coughlin said. “We’re very proud of what was accomplished a few years ago, but some of the phrases that are being used to identify this game and that game and the connections, I don’t necessarily agree with all of those.”

Even Coughlin, however, allows that the similarities between those Giants and these Giants are significant.

Both teams tore through the NFC playoffs with a deep and ferocious pass rush coupled with uncanny play by quarterback Eli Manning. Both won three consecutive road playoff games to reach the Super Bowl. And both won the NFC Championship Game in overtime on a field goal by Lawrence Tynes.

But, of the 22 players who started for New York four years ago on Super Bowl Sunday, just seven remain on the roster. New England has just five of its 22 starters still in house.

“There aren’t really a lot of us coaches and players who were involved in that game, and very few players, in relative terms, between both teams,” Patriots head coach Bill Belichick said. “We are where we are now, and we’re different than where we were earlier in the season. The Giants are where they are now, and I think they’re different than where they were at different points of the season. To take it back years and years before that, I don’t think it has too much bearing on anything. The team that wins Sunday will be the team that performs the best.”

On Nov. 6, in Foxborough, Mass., that team again was the Giants.

After a scoreless first half, New England took a 20-17 lead when Tom Brady connected with tight end Rob Gronkowski for a 14-yard touchdown pass with 1:36 left in the game.

Manning calmly drove New York 80 yards down the field for the winning score. With 30 seconds left, a 20-yard pass interference call against Patriots defensive back Sergio Brown put the ball at New England’s 1-yard line. And Manning hit tight end Jake Ballard in the end zone for the winning points with 15 ticks left on the clock.

“I’ve probably been asked 100 questions about our first Patriots game and the catches I had in that game and, ‘What do I think about the catches?,’” Ballard, who also had a 30-yard reception on the final drive, said. “It’s all well and great. It was good for me then. But I’m just trying to move past that. That was a great game and huge victory for the Giants this year. But we’re trying to have a bigger victory against them right now.”

New York struggled in the immediate aftermath of that victory, losing four straight and five of the next six overall. But the Giants caught fire on Christmas Eve against the rival New York Jets.

The NFC champions have won five straight games, by an average of nearly 15 points, and enter today’s game as a 3-point favorite.

It’s led to a level of confidence bordering on arrogance during Super Bowl week. But defensive tackle Chris Canty — who drew attention for referencing a potential victory parade during the week — said it’s all just part of New York’s us-against-the-world mentality.

“Let’s be honest, nobody believed in us to get to this point,” he said. “We’re here now. We’re playing good football. We’re a confident group, and we’re excited about the opportunity to go out there and play on Sunday.”

The Patriots are playing good football, too.

Their last loss came in that regular-season game against the Giants, and they have shown something of a lucky streak.

New England beat the Baltimore Ravens in the AFC Championship Game despite losing the turnover battle. Baltimore wide receiver Lee Evans briefly had the potential game-winning touchdown pass in his hands in the end zone late in the fourth quarter. And Ravens kicker Billy Cundiff shanked a 32-yard field goal that would have forced overtime.

But the Patriots’ 31st-ranked defense has vastly improved in the postseason, and Brady is playing as well as at any point in his storied career.

A victory Sunday would give Brady and Belichick four Super Bowl crowns, tying them with the Pittsburgh Steelers’ Terry Bradshaw and Chuck Noll as the most prolific quarterback-head coach combo in the event’s history.

“This is everything that you ask for as an athlete and as competitors,” Brady said. “I said (Tuesday) when you’re not playing in this game it sucks to turn on the TV these days. Every channel you turn on is talking about this game and the players in this game. As a competitor you want to be here, you need to be here.”

When kickoff arrives at 6:29 p.m., all the talk will be over.

The results of the game two months ago won’t matter. The results from four years ago will be a distant memory.

Nearly all the media experts in Indy this week are expecting a classic confrontation.

Three of the past four Super Bowls have been decided by six points or less. There’s no reason today’s game should be any different.

“If it’s the two best teams in football, it should come down to the wire,” Ballard said. “That means they’re playing a heck of a game on all fronts, and it should come down to the last possession or two.”

Text Only
Sports
  • DSC_1432.JPG Triumphant Tribe

    Seventeen years of frustration and disappointment for the Anderson Indians baseball team ended in a jubilant dog pile atop junior pitcher Curtis Wilson on Monday night at Pendleton Heights’ Field of Dreams.

    May 28, 2012 1 Photo

  • Argylls squeeze into crown

    Madison-Grant coach Ben Rodriguez liked his squeeze play so much that he called it again in the pivotal inning of the Class 2A, Sectional 39 championship game at Eastern High School on Monday night in Greentown.

    May 28, 2012

  • 0529 spts Lapel vs Wapahani_baseball 59a.jpg Bulldogs’ comeback falls just short

    Not even a heroic seventh-inning rally could save the Lapel baseball team in the Class 2A sectional title game at Frankton on Monday afternoon. The Bulldogs scored four runs in the seventh inning but still came up a run short as the Wapahani Raiders won the championship 9-8.

    May 28, 2012 1 Photo

  • 0413 sports Muller semifinal 038.jpg Tribe rallies past Pendleton Heights into final

    This is the stuff of legend.
    The kind of game that defines a rivalry.
    The kind of victory that breathes new life into a program.
    And the kind of defeat that won’t ever be forgotten.

    May 28, 2012 1 Photo

  • George Bremer-2.JPG George Bremer: In with Orton, out of Luck?

    There really is no offseason anymore in the National Football League.
    The Indianapolis Colts haven’t played a game since Jan. 1, but look at all the headlines they’ve generated since that date.

    May 28, 2012 1 Photo

  • 0528 NASCAR Charlotte Auto_Harl.jpg Kahne keeps Hendrick success rolling at Charlotte

    Kasey Kahne powered to victory in the Coca-Cola 600 on Sunday night, taking NASCAR's longest race for the third time for his first win with Hendrick Motorsports.

    May 27, 2012 1 Photo

  • 0528 Manu.jpg Spurs strike first in West finals, win 19th in row

    Manu Ginobili scored 26 points and the San Antonio Spurs won their 19th in a row to tie the NBA record for longest winning streak kept alive in the playoffs, beating the Oklahoma City Thunder 101-98 to open the Western Conference finals on Sunday night.

    May 27, 2012 1 Photo

  • Indians White Sox Bas_Harl.jpg Konerko hits go-ahead HR, White Sox sweep Indians

    Paul Konerko got a big milestone home run and the White Sox got a sweep of the only team between them and the AL Central lead.

    May 27, 2012 1 Photo

  • Rockies Reds Baseball_Harl.jpg Reds outslug Rockies on record day for HRs

    Here's how easy it looked to hit home runs at Great American Ball Park on Sunday: Todd Frazier lost his grip on the bat during a swing. The ball wound up in the seats anyway.

     

    May 27, 2012 1 Photo

  • Cubs Pirates Baseball_Harl.jpg Cubs lose 12th straight, 10-4 to Pirates

    The Chicago Cubs didn't come to close to ending their longest losing streak in more than 15 years. Pedro Alvarez, Andrew McCutchen and Garrett Jones homered, Erik Bedard pitched six shutout innings and the Pirates beat Chicago 10-4, sending the Cubs to their 12th consecutive loss.

     

    May 27, 2012 1 Photo