INDIANAPOLIS — Indiana schools chief Tony Bennett has never been afraid to ruffle a few feathers.
Since taking office in January, he's frustrated some school districts by changing a snow day policy and annoyed some lawmakers by opposing charter school limits.
But Bennett's latest proposal — one that would revamp teacher licensing standards — has sparked fierce opposition and created a turf battle between teacher colleges and the Department of Education that could come to a head Monday when the state holds its final public hearing on the issue in Indianapolis.
Hundreds of people have spoken out against the proposal, which calls for limiting the amount of teaching-method courses that future teachers take in college, as well as other changes.
Bennett, a Republican, said elementary education majors need to take more classes in the subjects they'll teach and that pedagogy — how to teach — should be limited to no more than 30 required credit hours combined of classes and student teaching. Under his plan, future teachers who want to teach middle school or high school would have to major in a subject area, such as math or English, and earn a minor in education.
Indiana University School of Education Dean Gerardo Gonzalez said it's "ludicrous" for Bennett to dictate the school's curriculum and essentially erode the school's secondary education major, which he said has about 200 students.
Bennett said he's just looking out for Indiana's schoolchildren.
"What effect this has on the IU School of Education really isn't my concern," Bennett said. "Probably some of this is a turf battle. They don't want to be told what to teach."
Gonzalez said IU uses sound research and feedback from students to create its curriculum — not an arbitrary limit on credit hours.
"The role of the state is to set high standards for teachers, then let the universities assign the curriculum," he said.
The Indiana Association of Colleges for Teacher Education, a group that includes public and private schools with teacher programs, also opposes many parts of the plan, said Kathy Moran, the group's president-elect and education dean at the University of Indianapolis.
Licensing changes earlier this decade shifted the focus from dictating the number and type of courses college students take before becoming teachers to results measuring whether those teachers are prepared, Moran said. Bennett's proposal goes the opposite direction, she said.
"It's really more a matter of taking us backward," Moran said.
The Indiana Department of Education says education schools have piled on pedagogy classes in recent years, and that it's trying to find the appropriate balance.
"You don't have to create a three-hour class for each and every individual skill that a teacher needs to have," Bennett said.
Gonzalez maintains that IU's education majors often take more subject classes than those majoring in the field. Former education students sometimes say they wish they had taken more courses in classroom management or other teaching methods but never complain about a lack of subject knowledge, he said.
Teachers must pass Praxis II subject matter exams before getting their license, and 100 percent of IU's education graduates pass the test, Gonzalez said. He thinks the state should simply raise the minimum passing scores on the exams if officials think teachers need a better understanding of the subjects they teach.
The state is considering doing just that, said Department of Education spokesman Cam Savage. Higher cut scores partnered with the new licensing rules would help ensure teachers are learning more content, Savage said.
Higher passing scores are not part of Bennett's current plan, but several other changes are part of the proposal.
The plan would allow school boards to hire principals and superintendents from business backgrounds or other careers outside the traditional education system. It also would allow current teachers to count certain professional development programs toward license renewal, possibly saving them money on tuition-based courses.
The Indiana State Teachers Association says it has concerns about some aspects of the plan but is trying to work with Bennett on compromises.
The Indiana Professional Standards Board will consider comments from the public hearings and the more than 800 comments submitted online before making any changes to the proposal.
Gonzalez said he hoped to see major revisions.
"They must take this testimony seriously," he said. "It would make a mockery of the entire process if we have thousands of people testify and at the end of the day it doesn't get taken seriously."
If the board approves some version of the plan and it clears other hurdles, the changes would take effect July 1, 2010.
State News
Debate heats up over revamped teacher license rule
- State News
-
-
10 Indiana measles cases confirmed; 1 at SB Village
Indiana health officials say the number of confirmed measles cases in central Indiana has grown to 10 children and adults.
-
Bedbugs found at Indianapolis children's hospital
An infestation of bedbugs discovered in a room at the Riley Hospital for Children has been contained, a spokeswoman for the Indiana University Health said Monday.
-
Court upholds convicted molester's sentence
The Indiana Court of Appeals has upheld a man's 20-year prison sentence for repeatedly sexually abusing a pre-teen girl.
-
Indiana court rules governor doesn't have to testify
The Indiana Supreme Court ruled Monday that Gov. Mitch Daniels doesn't have to answer questions under oath in a $400 million lawsuit that the state filed against IBM Corp. after he canceled the company's contract to process welfare applications.
-
INDOT: Plow truck drivers prepared for expected snow
The Indiana Department of Transportation Greenfield District will cover all snow routes in advance of winter weather expected late Monday and early Tuesday.
-
Proposed bill would streamline college credit transfer process
Indiana college students worried about whether their credit hours will transfer to another university may get some relief if a proposed higher-education bill passes.
-
Speedway will acquire 88 GasAmerica stores
Nine area GasAmerica stores will be sold to Speedway LLC of Enon, Ohio, as part of a larger acquisition of Gas America Services Inc., company officials said Monday.
-
First Merchants says Shelbyville acquisition will aid bottom line
First Merchants Bank believes its weekend acquisition of a failing Shelbyville bank will immediately add to the financial institution’s bottom line.
-
Shift to online learning raises questions about costs to schools
Legislation that would require high school students in Indiana to take at least one online course is meeting resistance from some school administrators who say they can’t afford any more mandates from the state.
-
Stolen car arrest in Spiceland leads to abducted New Jersey boy
Indiana authorities say a 6-year-old New Jersey boy abducted two months ago will be reunited with his father after a stolen car arrest led police to his whereabouts.
- More State News Headlines
-
10 Indiana measles cases confirmed; 1 at SB Village





